isn’t confined to Jewish congregations<\/a>)?<\/p>\nMaybe it has to do with budgets and dwindling memberships in many cases, which puts power in the hands of a small number of donors who can more easily call the shots. Or maybe it has to do with synagogues’ tendency to develop a small coterie of committed and interested individuals who come to dominate organizations mainly comprising dues-paying members who don’t attend synagogue more than once or twice a year.<\/p>\n
In some cases, financial considerations are to blame, as younger people aren’t joining the mega-shuls that their parents and grandparent erected over the course of the 20th century in North America, opting instead for less costly and more intimate worship options and leaving mega-shuls in financial peril.<\/p>\n
Perhaps it has to do with the sense that rabbis and other clergy are more like hired guns than spiritual leaders in modern consumer societies, particularly in cities like Toronto, which, with its large and vital Jewish community, is seen as a prime destination for clergy, so synagogues feel they can afford to be picky.<\/p>\n
Or perhaps the baby-boomer successors to the moral and scholarly giants of yesteryear truly do lack the intellectual gravitas of their predecessors. (I can think of a number of examples to bolster than opinion.)<\/p>\n
Or maybe it’s that the large-shul model has broken down for reasons of cost and cultural change, and those who still choose to affiliate with a mega-shul are increasingly bickering amongst themselves as they struggle to choose a direction that will keep the lights on and the whole enterprise afloat.<\/p>\n
More likely it’s due to a combination of factors, as well as the reality that it’s darned near impossible to please all of the people all of the time. And being a rabbi of a large synagogue is all about dealing with people \u2013 lots and lots and lots of people.<\/p>\n
Whatever the reason for all the turmoil, heckling the rabbi \u2013 if only under one’s breath or to the poor shmo in the next pew \u2013 is like a national pastime for Jews.<\/p>\n
I’ll bet rabbis Moscowitz and Allen wish it were something gentler, like knitting, or checkers.